JAMES Magazine Online: What Actually Happened with Those “Missing” Seminole Co. Votes?

Patrick Hickey

Friday, November 20th, 2026

To read all of JAMES Magazine Online’s daily news, SUBSCRIBE HERE. *Subscription includes a complimentary subscription to JAMES Magazine.

A Seminole County elections snafu made headlines last week when 388 “missing” votes were found after the fact, enough to swing the result of the race between Republican state Rep. Gerald Greene and Democrat Harry James – especially consequential with the extremely narrow margin in the Georgia House of Representatives.  

Even the most staid politico would raise an eyebrow at such a circumstance, when one candidate (James) goes to bed with a narrow lead, but then a missing memory card turns up that flips the result a day later.  But what really happened down in Southwest Georgia last week?

According to the Georgia Secretary of State’s office, county elections officials had “missed a memory card.” When it was found, the resulting votes flipped the lead from Democrat James back to Republican Greene.

“This oversight didn’t just affect the numbers — it changed who was leading an election,” Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger said. “That is unacceptable, and we intend to find out exactly how it happened.”

With details from Raffensperger’s office still fuzzy, and national Democrats and conspiracy theorists alike on high alert (fairly, in this case), enter Scrutineers, a national elections transparency organization who apparently isn’t afraid of putting boots on the ground.  The organization sent an investigator to Seminole County to look into the incident, and what they found turned out to be, surprisingly, pretty straightforward.  

The Scrutineers investigator spoke to Seminole County Elections Clerk Mike Rogerson, who explained that as he uploaded the memory cards for each precinct, he had “forgotten to click on SUBMIT” after uploading the election results from the Precinct 5 Election Day memory card.  Upon checking the initial upload of Seminole County’s Election Day results, that story lined up, as there were zero votes reported from Precinct 5.  

Meanwhile, the Scrutineers investigator filed an Open Records Request, allowing them to get a look at the physical poll tapes for Precinct 5.  Their findings confirmed the results – the precinct came back with 388 votes total, 344 for Republican Greene, and 34 for Democrat James.  No lost memory card, no scandal or conspiracy theory, just a simple election day error easily cleared up. 

“It’s unfortunate that something that can happen so easily on Election Night to any of our hard-working and exhausted election officials at the end of a hectic Election Day doesn’t seem to set off any system warnings or flags,” said Aileen Nakamura, president of Scrutineers. “I would hope ZERO votes from a precinct on Election Day would set off an immediate alert to check for errors.

On Monday the Seminole Co. elections office performed a ‘Risk Limiting Audit’ with 0% risk limit – also known as a full hand recount – of the State House District 154 race for all precincts, confirming the result once and for all.